Media
Putting the Hyper back in Hyper Local Journalism
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sat, 07/14/2007 - 14:37I received two interesting emails yesterday. One was from Roch Smith encouraging me to list my blog at We101. The other was the daily news from Digital Media Wire which included a pointer to their article about Citizen Journalism Site Backfence Shutting Down.
The Digital Media Wire talked about Backfence shutting down its 13 hyperlocal citizen journalism sites after having raised $3 million last October. There are plenty of people providing plenty of explanations about why Backfence has shut down, however, the comment that makes the most sense is from Mark Potts, a co-founder of Backfence, over in a discussion the Poynter Online:
As all of us who have tried to create hyperlocal communities know, doing so is incredibly hard. Turning them into a successful business is even harder.
Bringing in a sufficient return on investment (ROI) on $3 million is a big challenge for any hyperlocal journalism effort.
On the Poynter site, people were hypothesizing whether or not the amount of community outreach was sufficient. One of the things that has always made local journalism successful has been the connections with the local communities and I’ve often thought that people who try to strategize about the future of local newspapers don’t focus enough on the value of the connections with the local communities and how to monetize this in new ways with digital media.
Whether or not Backfence made sufficient efforts to reach out to local communities, I’ve also often felt that this is one of the biggest hurdles for new hyperlocal journalism sites.
This is where Roch comes in. Roch got involved in the local blogging community in Greensboro, NC back in around 2003. While he has not been attempting to bring sufficient ROI on $3 million, the organic growth of the Greensboro blogging community has been successful. He’s now expanding this by trying to provide a platform where similar blogging communities can emerge and evolve. I’ve joined up in Stamford, CT. I would encourage any of, especially, those of you who blog that are committed to building community to sign up if Roch has set up the platform to serve a local community that you live in.
Volunteer viral community organizing may be part of the key to helping hyper-local citizen journalism sites become successful. So, I’m spreading the virus, and I hope you will too.
A Birthday Wish
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 07/09/2007 - 16:07Let me start off by thanking everyone who has sent me birthday greetings. It is greatly appreciated. Birthdays can be a great time of reflection, especially if there are other big events going on, such as moving and trying to find a new job. It can be amplified if the birthday is a milestone or rapidly approaching one. For me, fifty is coming soon. That is well past halfway through the three score years and ten that poets of yesteryear wrote about, so please indulge a little mid life crisis reflections.
After dinner, I will blow out the candles on my birthday cake and make a birthday wish. What shall I wish for? Most practically, I’m wishing for a good job, but I’ve been wishing for that for a while. I’ve had various leads that looked promising, but never panned out.
How would I define a good job? Well, I realize that potential employers may come by and read my blog. I hope my description of my dream job doesn’t put off any of them if their opportunity isn’t precisely what I’m dreaming for. I sometimes feel as if that has happened in the past, and that perhaps I’m too much of a dreamer.
People who know me, and particularly my thoughts about writing know that I like to focus on the larger narrative. Yet I usually don’t think a lot about that narrative when I write my blog posts here. Instead, I’m finding a bit of it in retrospect.
Let me start off going way back. When I was young, I had a speech defect. I’m not sure how much I was ostracized for my funny way of speaking and how much I just felt that way, but I remember kids making fun of the way I spoke, even through high school. In college, I took some courses in speech pathology. I’ve always been searching for my own voice and been interested in helping others find their voices.
I had some poems published when I was in high school and college. I moved to New York City to become a writer. In the meantime, I supported myself working with computers. Now, nearly thirty years later, I still write and support myself by working with computers. Blogs have been a wonderful joining of the two.
When I was working as BlogMaster for John DeStefano’s campaign, I read a lot of local blogs and hyperlocal journalism sites. At the http://www.newhavenindependent.org/ >New Haven Independent, I came across posts by http://www.newhavenindependent.org/archives/gina_coggio/ >Gina Coggio. Gina was teaching English in a school in New Haven. She wrote wonderful accounts of her interaction with students in the school. I visited her class and encouraged them to take up blogging. Many of them had important stories to tell.
Back in September, 2005, I wrote in The New Orleans Metaphor,
It is my dream that just as Freedom Riders hopped on buses over forty years ago to help bring equality to blacks in the south we will see a new generation of people head to the Gulf Coast to help rebuild and help fight poverty.
In my mind, I thought of “Let Us Now Praise Famous Men”, redone for a new generation and a new media. I thought of bloggers and videobloggers writing about the Gulf Coast of today. I thought of people helping people along the Gulf Coast find their voice to describe their post-Katrina struggles, sort of like http://www.bloggercorps.org/ >BloggerCorps which never really got off the ground.
A month later, Sen. Edwards came to Yale as part of his Opportunity Rocks tour. I spoke about this idea with friends there. In Freedom Riders of the New WPA, I described the event:
If Senator Edwards does the standard leftover politics, I will be disappointed, but not surprised. I sure hope, however, that he will really talk about a new generation of Freedom Riders…
So, when Senator Edwards invoked the image of Robert Kennedy in Appalachia, my friend excitedly said, “That is exactly what you were talking about.” I wondered if this is what I’ve been hoping for.
Later, I was approached by the Edwards campaign about possibly working for them. I had dreams of being able to bring about a little bit of this vision. Perhaps my dreams were too big, perhaps they were looking for something else. Whatever it was, it never worked out for me to work with the Edwards campaign.
This year, on New Years, I wrote some similar thoughts in to help people find their voice. I spoke about it in terms of media reform. I’ve followed various leads for jobs with different non-profit organizations where I hoped I could bring about some of this vision. I spoke with Jay Rosen about trying to find ways to get this vision incorporated into some of his work with NewAssignment.Net.
Now, Sen. Edwards has announced his “Road to One America” Tour. It will start in New Orleans and end up in Prestonsburg, KY, where Robert Kennedy ended his trip in 1968. I hope the campaign has great local people blogging about the trip. More importantly, I hope that they spend some time helping people in New Orleans, and Prestonsburg and the towns and cities in between find their voices online. I hope these voices find their way into hyperlocal journalism, into Off the Bus, and find a persistence in our national dialog that enables politicians and non-profits to address the problem of poverty in our country.
And I do hope that I can find a job where I can help people find their voice.
Way Off The Bus
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 07/04/2007 - 11:07Recently, Zack Exley wrote an entry at Huffington Post entitled Time to Get Off the Bus. It is about the joint venture between NewAssignment.net and Huffington Post to get more citizen journalists covering the 2008 Presidential election.
Zack was also a cofounder of the New Organizing Institute which is doing a training in Washington DC right now. As part of the training, teams were formed to promote different fictional characters running for President. So, in the spirit of Off the Bus, I’m going to go way off the bus and present my fictional coverage of the campaigns.
The first candidate that I heard from was Lisa Simpson. Lisa’s supporters have a Facebook group up and can be reached at info@lisa2008.com. I’ve received several emails from the campaign urging me to spread the word. In the latest WOTB polls shows Lisa getting about 28% of the vote and running in second place. I learned about this from a friend on a regional blogging list.
The second candidate that I heard from was Stewie Griffen. I have not been able to find contact information or a Facebook group for Stewie. However, they are up on MySpace. Their website is taking advantage of some nice Blue State Digital features, and it isn’t a surprise that I heard about it from Clay Johnson. Unfortunately, they are going nowhere in the WOTB polling, showing up at 5th place with a whopping 1%.
Mr. Burns 2008 campaign was the third that I heard about. A friend of mine whom I know from a mailing list about the 2008 Presidential election contacted me about Mr. Burns campaign. Their Facebook group can be found here. In WOTB polling, they are currently in 3rd place with 21% of the vote.
The most recent campaign to catch my attention is Maggie for America. I found Maggie’s campaign when I stopped by at Rosalyn Lemieux’s page on Facebook. Maggie’s Facebook group is here. Rosalyn is the executive director of New Organizing Institute and having her in your Facebook group counts for a lot. It isn’t surprising that Maggie is leading in the WOTB poll with 36% of the vote.
Through more searching I’ve also found a campaign site for Krusty the Klown. Again, Roz links to his campaign on Facebook. Krusty is running fourth with 14% of the vote.
The blog that seems to be capturing most of the action on this campaign is the NOI Blog. I am picking up rumors that Homer Simpson, and Apu Nahasapeemapetilon are running. Yet details of their campaigns have remained elusive.
As of the deadline for this article, none of the campaigns have responded to inquiries about their positions, schedules or the food that they are eating on the road. Time and interest permitting, a followup will be posted.
All-American Presidential Forums on PBS
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Thu, 06/28/2007 - 08:30Yesterday, I received two interesting tidbits about the All-American Presidential Forums on PBS that will be happening this evening. The first was in a discussion with Robert Cox of the Media Bloggers Association (MBA). It was through the MBA that I received credentials for the Libby Trial. This time, they are working with PBS to credential bloggers to cover the Presidential Forums.
I have mixed feelings about credentialing processes. Too often they can be used to re-enforce a status-quo of who’s in and who’s out. MBA has done a great job of bringing in some of the bloggers that I consider some of the great under-recognized bloggers.
Faye Anderson will be blogging at Anderson@Large. I believe I first met Faye at the Media Giraffe summit back in 2006. She is a bright and engaging blogger, whom I’m pleased to see will be speaking at BlogHer at the end of July.
Another great blogger from New York City that will be there is Liza Sabater. Liza writes at culturekitchen, and The Daily Gotham. It seems like I run into at Liza at every blogging event, and she is always bringing up important questions. I really look forward to her coverage of the forums.
Terrance Heath, of the The Republic of T. is going to be there. I first met Terrance through the Progressive Bloggers Alliance and we were on a panel together in DC a few years ago. I haven’t seen him in a few years, but I still enjoy reading his blog.
Then, there are bloggers that I learned about through MBA. La Shawn Barber and I were supposed to be covering the Libby trial at the same time, and I started reading her blog because of this. We do not agree politically, and despite putting in lines like “Liberals are such crybabies”, she usually writes pretty insightful material.
I think I first stumbled across Kim Pearson through MBA. However, she writes so many interesting things, I may well have first read her writing about Second Life, some sort of media reform activities or something else. I’m glad she’ll be blogging the Presidential forum and I’m also glad to see that, like Faye, she will be speaking at BlogHer.
Another blogger that I really enjoy reading that will be part of the credentialed bloggers is Pam Spaulding. I’ve never met Pam, but I really enjoy reading Pam’s House Blend.
There are several other bloggers that I’ve read here and there but don’t really know or follow. I look finding out more about them. In many ways, I think I might be more interested in hearing from the bloggers who are credentialed than from the candidates themselves. MBA has set up this page to aggregate the feeds of these bloggers. It looks like a page worth watching.
If that is not enough, Michael Forbes Wilcox writes that Governor Deval Patrick will appear in the televised presidential debate. It was Michael and his friend Lori that first introduced me to Gov. Patrick and I echo Gov. Dean’s comment about Gov. Patrick, "Governor Patrick is a rising star in the Democratic Party and an outstanding example of the strong leadership vision and values that our party offers to American people."
While I didn’t think much of Wolf Blitzer hogging the spotlight at the debates in New Hampshire, I do hope that we see a lot of Gov. Patrick during the forums.
So, I’m excited about the forums. I’m excited to see Gov. Patrick. I’m excited to what the bloggers will say. I’m even hopefully that the candidates will have something interesting to say.
Edwards, Poverty and the New York Times
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Fri, 06/22/2007 - 19:40Well, it has been an interesting day. My diary over at DailyKos which I cross posted here got picked up by Huffington Post. Others have been writing great stuff about this as well, in particular, Greg Sargent has this great post about the Times article.
Some folks have suggested to me that I write to the public editor of the New York Times about the article. I have sent my letter to him, which I am including below the fold.
---