Archive - 2006
December 4th
How should 21st century media makers get paid?
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 12/04/2006 - 16:18(Cross posted at Greater Democracy)
It seems as if you can’t go a day without hearing about one newspaper or another cutting staff. The return on investment in the newspaper industry isn’t what investors want, and reporters are finding themselves out of work. Meanwhile on bloggers’ mailing lists, people are asking how they can make blogging pay. On top of this, large foundations are making grants to promote digital media, citizen journalism, hyperlocal news, and so on.
As a person who has had the good fortune to be paid for blogging, I sometimes feel like I’m in the middle of this maelstrom, but I hope I can suggest a few ways in which other bloggers can better support their habit.
This weekend I was at RootsCampDC. It was a gathering of progressive political activists where the issue of how blogging communities can be better supported came up many times. Groups like BlueNC, Raising Kaine, Blue Jersey, MyLeftNutmeg, and BlueMassGroup were repeatedly praised for their roles in the 2006 midterm elections.
Another site that got lots of praise was ActBlue. Could ActBlue be used as a fundraising tool for regional blogs? ActBlue already does fundraising for various national PACs, and it would seem reasonable for them to fundraise for regional blogs. The question that would need to be addressed is how such blogs would organize. Would they be a Federal PAC, a State PAC, a 527, a 501(c)4, a 501(c)3, or some other sort of LLC or other organization? I am not a campaign finance lawyer, so I’ll leave those sort of questions to others to address.
Beyond supporting existing regional blogging communities, the question arises of how to grow additional regional blogging communities. There were a lot of folks from the DNC at RootsCamp and one good session was about the nuts and bolts of the 50 State Strategy. People from New Jersey and Virginia spoke about how the folks from the DNC interacted with BlueJersey and Raising Kaine. It was suggested that part of the tasks that DNC staffers out in the states do is to help build a regional blogosphere. Folks from Democracy for America were also there and there were discussions about what sort of training programs DFA should be considering. Several people suggested technology related programs, but perhaps a program on building regional blogospheres would be a good topic. There were even representatives from potential 2008 candidates saying interesting things about how their probable campaigns were hoping to change the media landscape.
During a break, one of the attendees pointed me to this op-chart in the New York Times (NewsTrust Review). More and more bloggers are getting paid by campaigns. The Op-Chart seems to look at this negatively, but I view it as a positive development and I hope many of my friends interested in advocacy can find jobs blogging for campaigns, as well as for non-profits and other groups needing to find new ways to get their message out.
One of my concerns about the Times Op-Chart is that continue to promote a stereotype of bloggers as activists that have “contempt for the political establishment”. While there maybe bloggers whose activism is driven by contempt for the political establishment, there are many more bloggers driven by a love for our country and an interest in using new tools, both inside and outside of the political establishment to make our country even better. There are also a lot of bloggers that seek to bring about better journalism through the blogosphere, in part, perhaps, in reaction against the shoddy journalism they see in the mainstream media.
Because of this, I think some bloggers might do well to start thinking of themselves in terms of hyperlocal, digital, citizen journalists, or some such combination of adjectives. There is growing interest in funding these sort of journalists and I think a lot of bloggers could benefit from embracing more of what is good happening in changes to journalism.
The changes in the media landscape will continue to affect the way media producers are compensated. Hopefully people can find ways of using these changes to be able to support themselves and to support a much more vibrant media ecosystem.
December 3rd
Congrats NaNoWriMo Girl!
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sun, 12/03/2006 - 14:00
The cake that we got to celebrate Miranda completing the first draft of her first novel as part of the National Novel Writing Month (NaNoWriMo)
November 29th
NaNoWriMo
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Thu, 11/30/2006 - 02:01An IM from Miranda:
(MirandashiddenIMName): I FINISHED NANOWRIMO!
(MirandashiddenIMName) is away at 10:45:46 PM.
NANOWRIMO is short for National Novel Writing Month. Miranda has just finished the first draft of her first novel. A major accomplishment. I am very happy.
November 28th
NewsTrust goes to Public Beta
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 11/28/2006 - 14:34For the past several months, I’ve been working with NewsTrust. NewsTrust is a site where people review news stories for their journalistic quality. Over on NewsTrust, I wrote,
"I started using NewsTrust early on, in an effort to find those news stories that were better than average. I've found many great stories this way. As I've gotten more involved, I've started reviewing and submitting stories myself. It has caused me to stop, think and learn more about what makes for better journalism. With this, I've come to better appreciate some news sources that I've not always favored, as I've come to see some of their better journalism. "
Today, with the launch of the public beta, I’ve been promoting the site at various places. I set up a diary on DailyKos about NewsTrust. CTNewsJunkie picked up the story, as did Connecticut Local Politics. ScienceBlogs wrote about it, and I put up posts on MyLeftNutmeg and One America.
e pluribus media has added NewsTrust to their blog roll. I’ve added a feed of top stories from NewsTrust onto my site.
Another great article on NewsTrust can by found at Rory O’Connor’s Blog, and The Kentucky Democrat makes a brief mention of NewsTrust yesterday.
So, NewsTrust is off and running. For the incurable cynics around me, I’ve been involved with NewsTrust because I believe in what they are doing, and not because of any hope of monetary compensation for promoting their site. As to what happens next, I think Rory sums it up best, “What happens next is up to you.”
Update: Also, check out the posts The Editor's Weblog and Media Giraffe Project about NewsTrust.
November 27th
Can Social Marketing Save the World?
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 11/27/2006 - 18:35On Tuesday, I will be participating in a panel at Wesleyan entitled Can Social
Marketing Save the World?
In preparation, I wanted to pull up various videos that tie together some of my thoughts. The first is the trailer for The Ad and the Ego.
First, I think we need to re-evaluate our relationship to advertising, and particularly in terms of thinking about the subtext of advertisements. As I've written before, I believe that the subtext of most political advertisements, especially the ones that dominiated the recent elections is We Think You're Stupid. To me, one of the most important underlying messages of the Lamont campaign was one of participation.
In the first campaign ad we saw people rushing in, even before the advertisement was completed, and the introduction of the 'and so do we' theme.
There are two pieces online about how the media landscape is changing. The first is Epic and the second is Day of the Longtrail. They both talk about more citizen involvement with shaping our media. I really wanted to see and encourage citizen involvement in shaping the media for the campaign, because I believe that is a key part of how the change we are hoping for needs to come about.
Perhaps one of the best examples of what worked in the Lamont campaign was when CT Bob created this video. Later, the campaign created a similar ad.
Things that I would have liked to have seen, that didn't happen was people creating Machinima and doing other things to use games and other online tools to get the message out.
I believe that we can use social marketing to save the world. I believe that campaigns are a start to that, but that we need to go beyond campaigns, and that the key starting point is get more people involved in thinking critically about media and creating their own media.