Archive - 2007
August 9th
With Liberty and Justice for All
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Thu, 08/09/2007 - 09:03Tuesday, I was at the National Conference of State Legislatures listening to panelists talk about education and results based accountability. I’ve wondered about the unintended results in education. I touched on this briefly in a post about the Freedom of Information complaint filed against the Lewis S. Mills School in Burlington, CT.
Andy Thibault has been following this closely at Cool Justice and pointed me to Chris Powell’s wonderful column Inadvertently, school teaches about liberty.
Doninger and her friends also were forbidden to wear to school T-shirts with inscriptions supporting freedom of speech.
It all will be a nice counterpoint to the next recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag at Mills High School, what with its proclamation of "liberty and justice for all."
Powell’s article captures very nicely the truly teachable moment taking place at Lewis S. Mills School. Yet for teachable moments to take place, people must know about them and Thibault and Doninger are providing an important service in bringing attention to this teachable moment. I hope it spreads.
Being the instigator that I am, I hope the students and teachers at Lewis S. Mills school all return to school wearing T-shirts that simply say “Liberty and Justice for All”. Will the school, in the middle of this lawsuit send students home for wearing a quote from the Pledge of Allegiance? How will the administration treat teachers that try to use a teachable moment to encourage students to think seriously about what the Pledge of Allegiance means?
Beyond that, I do hope that the administration comes to its senses soon and settles out of court. Wise educators know not only when to take advantage of a teachable moment, but they also know when it is time to move on with the lesson plan. I hope such a settlement includes a way to bring closure to the teachable moment.
To me, the best closure would include a school assembly with Thibault, Powell and others on a panel talking about the importance of vigilantly protecting liberty and justice for all, followed by the musical event that precipitated the whole morass. I also hope college admission officers around the country take note and fight hard to recruit Avery Doninger.
I remain the optimist. I do believe in liberty and justice and all, and I salute Doninger, Thibault, Powell and everyone who is standing up it.
- Aldon Hynes's blog
- Login to post comments
- Comments
August 8th
Wordless Wednesday
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 08/08/2007 - 07:17August 7th
NCSL New Ways to communicate with constituents
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 08/07/2007 - 14:47A group of around 100 people gather to learn about new ways to communicate with constituents at the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL). Paul Taylor from the Center for Digital Government at Government presides. He starts off by showing a YouTube video from the digital ethnologists in Kansas.
The first speaker is Delegate Kristen Amundson from Virginia. She blogs at 7 West. She starts off with some standard old stereotypes of bloggers, tattooed and pierced. As a forty-eight year old blogger, I challenge that stereotype. However, looking around the room of around a hundred people interested in new ways to communicate with constituents, only one other person has a laptop open.
Getting past the stereo types, she has some great comments. First, she talks about how it is inexpensive and a technological neophyte like herself could easily get going. Beyond that she talks about the importance of it being a community. She only had to remove one comment, despite the tendency for blogs to sound a bit like drunks in a bar. As to whether you can have staff do it, she comments, “It’s your voice, if you can’t do it yourself, don’t have your staff do it.”
She has a comment about blogging not being just a joy ride, it is a responsibility.
To get around the drunk in a bar feeling of some blogs, she uses WebDialogues. She describes the discussions there as a League of Women’s Voters panel on Steroids.
She describes them as two very different experiences, and that you should do both. She notes that people who take parts in a web dialogs have an increased view belief that their votes matter, and the have a more favorable impression of legislators that use web dialogs.
Next up is Steve Urquhart from Utah. Theme one: Improve your legislative website. Theme two: (In line with Tom Friedman’s comment) Do it with them, or they will do it to you. Finally: it has to be a bottom up approach.
He starts off by illustrating Deval Patrick’s site where people talk about issues, such as Shared Parenting. It is a good site, but lacks the ability for people to talk back and forth. Again, he notes that constituents will do it no matter what. He also talks about the lack of ability for people to organize the issues.
He talks about the importance of having your quotes online so that reporters can get the quote right.
The next site he mentions is the 10 Downing Street ePetitions effort. He moves on to what Barack Obama has on his campaign site. He notes this is campaign oriented and raises the issue of how campaign sites compare with issues sites for people who are actually elected. He goes to the Obama Senate site, which is very 1.0 without linking to constituents. He notes that this isn’t different from any of the other candidates who are currently in office.
He goes on to talk about people working together in Burlington , VT, thanks to a site, Front Porch Forum. It is great community building and they will talk about the candidates with or without the candidates participating.
The next site he illustrates is Knowledge as Power to facilitate interactivity between citizens and their elected officials.
He talks about his own blog where you can interact with less filters, showing your sense of humor, your normal pursuits and see that you are just a normal person. He talks about the importance of having a more human face online and that politics is happening online, and that is where you need to be.
The third speaker is Sue Gullufsen, from the Legislative Affairs Agency in Alaska. She talks about meetings that they have held through their Legislative Information Offices, which are often the only Government agency in an area. She brings in Marie Murray from the Sitka LIO and Allison from another LIO. Then Emily Frisbee from Glenallen speaks about their Legislative Information Office.
During the Q&A, Steve mentions Politicopia which he describes as the first legislative Wiki. Steve also talks about the lack of good dialog online, and the desire to create better dialog online.
Con Hogan Award Luncheon
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 08/07/2007 - 12:55This afternoon at the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) annual meeting in Boston, the Connecticut Joint Appropriations Committed and the State Office of Policy and Management are receiving the first Con Hogan Award. Con Hogan is former Secretary of the Vermont Agency for Human Services.
Connecticut is being recognized for “their achievements in considering how state spending affects key outcomes for Connecticut families and the environment.” The buzzword of the day is “results based accountability”.
Speakers include Sen. Bob Duff, Sen. Toni Harp, Rep Denise Merrill, Rep. Diana Urban, Robert Genuario from the Office of Policy and Management and Susan Shimelman, from the Office of Fiscal Analysis.
Numerous other notables from Connecticut are here include Rep Steve Fontana, Rep Tom Reynolds, Rep. Peter Williams, Rep. John Geragosian, and Rep. Jason Bartlett. Members of AFT are here as well as former Norwalk Mayor Alex Knopf.
Jack Tweedle starts off by commenting about wanting to get other people to know about what is going on in Connecticut and other states doing “results based accountability”.
(Cross posted to MyLeftNutmeg)
August 6th
NCSL: Monday morning random notes.
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 08/06/2007 - 19:43Last night I went out to Moules and Frites at Central Kitchen. Kim had searched online and recommended it. My searches came up with similar recommendations, so I headed over and ate at the bar. I was down at the end of the bar where staff chatted and I had a good discussion with some of them. It was the birthday of one of the bartenders and his girlfriend came in and talked with the waitresses about different trips that they had been taking. It helped keep the annual meeting in context.
This morning, as I walked to the convention hall I passed John from Below Boston. He is passing out Obama stickers to anyone interested. He says that he has gotten a lot of thumbs up.
I sit next to a delegation of legislators from South Africa as I have some breakfast. During the morning networking, I run into Rep. Steve Fontana and Rep. Diane Urban. They are talking with former Norwalk Mayor Alex Knopf. Mayor Knopf’s name tag also has a green ribbon indicating that he is a member of the press. He disappears before I get a chance to find out which press outlet.
For the first session, I walk past the “Public Hearing on Internet and Electronic Commerce - Breakfast”. The program describes the event as follows:
The committee will conduct a public hearing to solicit the viewpoints of consumers and industry representatives regarding NCSL’s Internet and Electronic Commerce Policy Statement.
…
Presiding: Representative Phil Montgomery, Wisconsic
Speaker: K. Dane Snowden, CTIA – The Wireless Association, Washington, D.C.
NCSL gratefully acknowledges the sort of CTIA – The Wireless Association for breakfast.
I wonder which consumers they solicited viewpoints from. Most of the sessions you have to be a registered attendee of the annual meeting to enter. I had considered seeing if they would let me testify, even though I’m here as part of the press. In the end I decided not to engage. However, it does seem like the industry representatives are all over this and there isn’t a lot of consumer viewpoints being expressed.
Instead, I go to the session, “Capital Hill Tackles Climate Change”. There was a large turn out to the Climate change session, a couple hundred people. It was even better attended than the internet and electronic commerce session. Nikki Roy, from the Pew Center on Global Climate Change spoke about the chances of meaningful climate change legislation over the next few years. A staffer for Rep. Markey spoke about climate change, and Eric Holdsworth of the Edison Electric Institute (EEI) spoke about the industry’s response. EEI represents the shareholder owned utilities, which make up around 85% of the electricity generated in the United States.
He noted that in 1994 they signed a memorandum of understanding to voluntarily cut greenhouse gases. They went on to sign agreements with the Bush administration. He claimed that the EIA is projecting energy growth of 43% BY 2030. This is based on population growth and changes in energy consumption patterns. The numbers seem high to me, but I do know the assumptions that were used. Also, my assumptions are that we will see people conserving energy and finding new ways to be more energy efficient. As a side note, in the exhibition hall, America Electric Power was giving away compact fluorescent lightblubs. On the other hand, if we ever get plug-in hybrids or other electric vehicles, that could increase the demand.
He argued for an energy policy that included all the current sources of electricity. He mentioned that New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Oregon and Washington State all have CO2 regulations in effect. He spoke about Illinois, Texas and Wyoming having Carbon Capture and Storage systems in place.
During the questions and answers, one person asked about wind. He noted that the wind is always blowing somewhere and that by putting up windmills in places like North Dakota, Wyoming and Texas considerable renewable energy could be tapped. He talked about the need for a smarter grid to get that energy from the windmills to cities where the energy demand is greater. I hadn’t really thought about the grid issues. There are enough battles over simply the placement of windmills, such as you find with Cape Wind. The issues of transmission lines, as they’ve been fought over with new lines in Fairfield County or cables going under Long Island Sound only exacerbate the issue.
All in all, the session was long on speech making, a little short on details, but did have some bright spots.