Media
The Future of News and Detroit – The Dying Goat
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Thu, 04/09/2009 - 15:41As stories about further cutbacks and closures in the newspaper industry continue, so do discussions about what is wrong with the news industry, and what can be done to fix it. However, many of the discussions seem to be looking at the problem from the wrong end. Too many people are looking at trying to adjust the revenue stream to deal with online distribution, and too few people are talking about the product itself, the news.
The story of the demise of newspapers follows a familiar line. Something has come along to challenge the hegemony of the industry. For the newspapers, it is the Internet. Classifieds have moved to Craigslist. Subscribers are getting their news online. It reminds me an awful lot of the auto industry years ago. For them, it was Japan. Everyone was buying Japanese cars. They blamed the labor unions. They blamed heathcare costs and retirement costs. What no one was willing to talk about was the big issue, they stopped making a product that people cared about. Sounds a lot like the newspapers today.
Sure, they managed to buy some time making SUVs which people liked for a while, until gas prices went up again. Likewise, the news industry managed to buy sometime by providing entertainment in the guise of news, by focusing on personalities like O’Reilly or Olberman and not on information people needed.
When I spoke with one old newspaper man, he talked about the day when newspapers were run by local companies. They were part of the community and were something that people cared about. There was a high return on investment. So, the big investors came in and tried to run the papers. They tried to squeeze even more return out of the papers.
It was sort of like the story of the farmer and his goat. He figured that he could make more money off of his goat if he cut her food with sawdust. Slowly, he started replacing more and more of her food with sawdust. The goat’s milk production went down a little, but the farmer made up for the lost milk revenue with the savings he was getting on grain. Kept doing that until finally the goat starved to death.
That, I believe, is the real issue with both the car industry and the news industry. People have been busy saving money by delivering sawdust and calling it news. Now that the readers are leaving, people are wondering if maybe they can do something different to get readers again. The answer is simple, start producing news again.
Write about things that you care about and that your community cares about, and you’ll find readers. Until then, the discussions about revenue models are a bit like discussions of whether you try to milk your dying goat before or after you feed it more sawdust.
Ted Turner and Ned Lamont at #ccsu
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 04/07/2009 - 19:05New Britain – Tuesday afternoon, as a stop on Ted Turner’s whirlwind speaking tour of Connecticut, Ted, as he insists on being called, together with Ned Lamont spoke to a large group of students and guests at Central Connecticut State University (CCSU).
In a rapid fire chat, Ned, who was introduced as a distinguished professor of political science, started off by introducing Ted, asking a few preliminary questions, and turning it over to a long question and answer question with the crowd.
One of the first questions was what students who are about to graduate from CCSU should consider for their careers. Mr. Turner, who made a fortune off of television, starting with a small UHF channel, and ultimately launching CNN, TBS and owning the Atlanta Braves, suggested staying away from television. There are 200 channels out there already, he said. No, Ted suggested, replacing Mr. McGuire’s line “Plastics” from The Graduate: “Clean Renewable Energy”. He spoke about his own investments in solar and his plans to expand his investments in other forms of clean renewable energy.
Concerning politics, Ted recounted when he met Fidel Castro. He asked Castro why Cuba was operating in Central America, and Castro asked Turner why the United States was operating in Central America. It provided an important underlying theme for his talk. Don’t expect other countries not to do things that the United States is doing.
He returned to this theme later when he spoke about nuclear proliferation. If we want countries to not have nuclear weapons, we need to lead by example. He talked about the 1968 non-proliferation treaty, and read part of it about countries seeking to decrease the number of nuclear weapons and suggested that the United States was doing about as good on that treaty as it had on treaties with Native Americans.
Early on, he spoke about endangered species. When he spoke about ‘godless commies’, a line that received a laugh, he suggested that communists are perhaps more of an endanger species that various animals on the endangered species list.
On the media, he spoke about the importance of news organizations focusing on delivering news, and not on presenting personalities. When asked about media consolidation, he quipped that he only approved of it if he was the one in charge of consolidated media. It was part of a long rambling set of questions that also talked about profits in media, to which Ted asked what profits had to do with media consolidation.
He suggested that it was the Internet that was the demise of newspapers. In a discussion after the main event, he went on to say that the problem is that newspapers haven’t adjusted their business model to deal with the instantaneous and less expensive delivery of news that the Internet provides.
He had a quick witty response to just about every question that was thrown at him, until the final question. He was asked what one thing that he learned over his seventy years did he wish he had learned earlier.
He did not come up with a specific thing that he had learned, but he noted that his greatest regret was that he had three failed marriages. He spoke about having remained on friendly terms with his ex’s and even did a plug for ’33 Variations’ which is now on Broadway starring his ex-wife Jane Fonda.
Always on the run, he spoke briefly with alumni and guests at a special reception before running off to his next event. This nonstop energy has led to many of his greatest successes, but also probably contributed to the demise of his marriages.
#FollowFriday
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Fri, 04/03/2009 - 09:00@acarvin @blogdiva @stevegarfield @jillmz @tishgrier @waynesutton @ chuckumentary @mlsif
Each Friday I try to highlight some of the interesting people that I follow on Twitter. Since Twitterfeed puts the beginning of my blog post on Twitter, I can just post my #FollowFriday post here, along with my thoughts about it and it will show up on Twitter.
This week, I highlighting some of the people I really like in the social political media complex. Some of the names are very well known, others less so. I’ve also not included some of the obvious big names because they don’t need highlighting, and also, in part, because I don’t feel like I’m in a conversation with them, the way I feel that I have been in conversations with some of the folks above. With that, let me talk about the people in this weeks #FollowFriday
Andy Carvin @acarvin is the social media swami at National Public Radio. He has highly informative tweets, nicely mixed with the personal experience. He’s gotten people like Scott Simon and Dan Schorr onto Twitter.
I don’t recall exactly when I first met Liza Sabater, @blogdiva. It was probably around 2003 or 2004 and had probably had to do with the nexus of politics and technology. Like Andy, Liza’s posts are informative and nicely mixed with personal experience.
Steve Garfield, @stevegarfield can be described as the father of videoblogging. I think I first met Steve at MediaGiraffe a couple years ago. You should follow not only Steve’s tweets, but especially his video work.
Tish Grier @tishgrier is perhaps not as well known in the Twittosphere as Andy, Liza or Steve. Yet she has been making her voice heard for many years and it is great to hear her voice on Twitter. I’ve met her at several news media related events.
Like Tish, Jill Miller-Zimon @jillmz is also not as well known as Andy, Liza or Steve. I’ve only met Jill once face to face, at election night coverage at NPR Studios last November. However, we’ve known each other online for a while and I now live in the town she grew up in. As with others, I first ran into Jill online some place other than Twitter. Again, I don’t recall the details, but it was probably when one of us commented on the others blog.
Wayne Sutton @waynesutton. Like Jill, I’ve only met Wayne once face to face, which was at a conference about news media in Lowell, MA. Like myself, Wayne seems to experiment with just about every online site that comes along, and I’ve enjoyed interacting with Wayne on many of these sites.
Chuck Olsen @chuckumentary I believe I only met Chuck once, which was at a media event when John Edwards was first entering the 2008 Presidential Primary. While his own blog and twitter stream are well worth the read, the real reason I mention Chuck is his work with @theuptake which provides an important and fascinating glimpse into Minnesota.
Let me end off this week with Micah Sifry @mlsif. I believe that the first time I met Micah was at the inaugural Personal Democracy Forum back in 2004. PDF has grown over the years and continues to be a focal point of the social political media complex.
So, that’s this week’s #FollowFriday. See you on Twitter.
CT News Wire at Two Weeks
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 03/31/2009 - 19:54Two weeks ago, I set up CT News Wire. Over this time, I’ve been trying to come up with as concise a statement about what CTNewsWire is and made efforts to get people to start using it.
CTNewsWire is a public mailing list for state and local agencies, elected officials, candidates and advocacy organizations in Connecticut to use to more effectively communicate with the constantly changing world of bloggers and citizen journalists.
There are 115 state agencies in Connecticut, 169 municipalities, 151 State Representatives, 36 State Senators and numerous advocacy agencies. Many of them send out press releases to what seems to be an ever-decreasing pool of traditional journalists. Their communications directors don’t have easy ways to find new people, such as bloggers and citizen journalists that might be interested in receiving their press releases, and new bloggers and citizen journalists can find it difficult to get on the media lists of all the groups they are interested in.
So, I set up a CTNewsWire Google Group that anyone can subscribe to, and anyone can send media advisories to. During the first few weeks, I forwarded some of the press releases I received to the group and started contacting communications directors and public information officers. I also started to slowly spread the word about CTNewsWire.
It is still just a small handful of bloggers and citizen journalists that subscribe to CTNewsWire, but the number is growing. More importantly, the number of communications directors starting to use CTNewsWire has grown.
With that, let me highlight three events coming up over the next few days that I found out about via CTNewsWire.
#followfriday – CT News Edition
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Fri, 03/27/2009 - 09:46@hartfordcourant @wherewelive @connpost @rep_am @CTNewsJunkie @hrtfordadvocate @NwHavenAdvocate @FairfieldWeekly
In last week’s #followfriday, I highlighted some of my friends from Connecticut that are on Twitter. This week, @joeCascio and @keachymama are doing CT Editions of #followfriday, so I decided to stay with it.
My list this week is of Connecticut media outlets on Twitter. I hope the list is obvious to everyone. The Hartford Courant. WNPR’s show, “Where We Live”. The Connecticut Post. The Waterbury Republican American, the great online site covering the State Capital, CTNewsJunkie, and the weekly entertainment alternatives the Hartford Advocate, the New Haven Advocate and the Fairfield Weekly.
Each of these are worth a follow to get information about what is happening in our state.
Am I missing any? Who else do you follow?