Wordless Wednesday
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 03/11/2009 - 08:49#EngageExpo Day 1 Recap
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 03/11/2009 - 08:28During rough economic times, conferences are often hit particularly hard. People don’t have the funds to travel, vendors cut back on their displays, yet the information at conferences remain as valuable as ever, if not more so. Engage! Expo is no different. I’ve run into some old friends at the conference and I’ve established new relationships. I’ve picked up my small amount of swag and taken copious notes.
The first keynote was a talk by David Luner, SVP of Interactive and Consumer Products for FreemantleMedia Enterprises and Teemu Huuhtanen, EVP of marketing and business development for Sulake. They talked about the deal between their companies to bring American Idol into Habbo. There was the standard discussions about other co-marketing efforts, such as American Idol’s deals with Barbie, Dreyer’s Ice Cream, McDonalds, iTunes and Disney. There were discussions of the demographics of Habbo; heavily teen, with a strong influence in Europe and Latin America.
Yet for me, the most interesting part, and one that brought a question was about why American Idol chose to co-brand with an existing virtual world instead of building their own. There were comments about American Idol wanting best in class for virtual worlds and their belief that they were unlikely to do a better job than Habbo had already done, and the risk to the brand of a failed virtual world launch was greater than any upside opportunity that having their own virtual world might have produced. They noted that by using an existing platform, they could launch more quickly.
I view this as a good sign in the movement away from siloed virtual worlds towards a more common virtual space. At the end of the session, Ted Tagami, VP of Business Development for SmallWorlds spoke briefly about their world. They are moving even further towards better interoperability as they connect with Facebook and Bebo and prepare to support OpenID authentication.
The first panel that I attended was Virtual Worlds By The Numbers: A Look at the Market Research. Barry Gilbert, VP and Research Director for Strategy Analytics and Michael Cai, VP of Research in Video Games for Interpret also focused on the move towards interoperability. WeeMee’s integration with Skype and AIM were noted. Mr. Gilbert said they were expecting continued interaction with social networks, some consolidation in the virtual world space as venture capital is reduced during the recession, increased avatar portability, and the emergence of standardized metrics. He noted that the typical user that he was studying was in around four virtual worlds, but they are typically only active in one or two as virtual worlds seek stickiness. The number of virtual worlds the average user is in is trending down, a trend he expects to see continue.
Michael Cai’s presentation provided other interesting information. He spoke about the virtual world space as still being dominated by early adopters, whereas the gaming space has spread across much of the technology adoption curve. He spoke about research into brand preferences of virtual world participants. As I think about the current financial problems, I was struck by a screen about views on automobiles. Virtual world residents currently own cars made by Ford, Toyota and Honda, in that order. Dodge came in fourth. GM barely made the list. For cars that virtual world residents hope to own in the future, Toyota and Honda both remained in the top three, and Ford, the top American brand dropped to fifth.
Another interesting tidbit about virtual world residents is that they have a tendency to be more physically active, exercising at home or at the gym and participating in cycling, basketball, track, football and soccer. They also tended to be more socially active than the population of general Internet users.
After lunch, a different panel took up the metrics issue talking about Virtual World Metric = Measuring Engagement. This area is still emerging and most frequently people look at this in terms of time spent on a site and number of click-throughs. One person suggested that the average time on the typical website is around fifteen seconds, whereas the average time spent in a virtual world was more like ten minutes. He claimed that click-throughs averaged 1-5% in virtual worlds and only fractions of a percent on traditional websites.
Yet Dr. James M. Bower, Founder, Chairman and CVO of Numedeon, which runs Whyville, had a very different perspective. He spoke about how virtual worlds makes marketing about the product and no longer just about the brand. He spoke about information that he could provide to companies about how people interacted on a product by product basis. He had an interesting comment about twelve year-olds interacting with a product in Whyville and ending up knowing more about the product than the salespeople selling the product. He suggested that the metrics used for education are probably going to be the best metrics for virtual worlds. He noted the old adage, “All marketing is really education.”
Here, he wasn’t talking about the sort of metrics that are too often looked at in education, scores on standardized tests about material learned. Instead he was talking about metrics measuring student retention, engagement, contextualization and related ways of measuring how involved the students really are.
He suggested that as we move away from a focus on eyeballs, to a focus on eyeballs connected to brains, everything changes and that it will put more pressure on companies to produce better products. He also spoke about how whenever a new technology comes along, people tend to try and do things they knew how to do with older technology with the new technology, instead of rethinking the way the approach the underlying issues.
The final panel I attended was Parallel Virtual Worlds and the Transformation of Browsing the Web. This discussion was moderated by Benjamin Duranske of Pillsbury, and included Steven Hoffman, CEO of RocketOn. Jan Andressen, CEO of Weblin was also supposed to participate but did not make it. Keith McCurdy of Vivaty also joined the panel.
I asked about interoperability at this panel, and one of the panelists really went off on how we won’t see interoperability for a long time and how it is a bad thing for all of the virtual world providers. It turns out that by interoperability, he was thinking about seamlessly moving avatars and assets from one world to another. Instead, he suggested that we might see ‘interchangability’, the ability to import and export some information from one virtual world to another. Interchangability, he suggested, seemed much more reasonable and likely, but still not in the near term. This led to some confusion, since no one had heard the term interchangability before and it sure sounded a lot like what I meant, and I suspect many others mean by interoperability. One of the other panelists spoke about his project already supporting some sorts of interoperability, by, for example, basing text communications on Jabber. This is a topic that deserves much more discussion, and I hope to write a longer blog post about this when the dust settles.
As I wrapped up the first day at Engage Expo, I had the opportunity to speak with Thom Kidrin, President and CEO of Worlds.com. Worlds.com is about to DMC World as a hip-hop and music lovers virtual world. Like the discussion of interoperability, this is a topic that deserves a blog post of its own.
After the conference, people gathered at various bars around town. I went down to the Half King Pub and chatted with folks there. One discussion that needs follow up is one that I had with Carol Altarescu of Privo. How does their effort fit with portable contacts and other issues of ‘privacy, permission and trust’? I don’t know the answer yet, so that will have to wait for another day as well.
So, while Engage Expo seemed smaller this year in terms of participants, at least the first day seemed very full of important information. Now, on to day two.
Engage the Existentialist
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 03/10/2009 - 09:02And what about the best minds of our generation? They aren’t doing anything as romantic as Ginsburg’s friends, searching the angry gutter for a fix. No, some have been searching for ways to use technology to engage people in politics or non-profits. Others ride the subways joining blank faces beneath the pictures of smiling models. At the end of the day, they get cynical and drunk and boring someone in some sad café, or maybe these days some sad virtual world.
At their jobs, they try to find ways of separating their fellow human beings from their hard earned wages, perhaps by trying to come up with an engaging advertisement in one of these virtual worlds. It almost feels like Freeport in Neuromancer. Yet, perhaps, the joy that some people see as their hard earned wages get stripped from them in some virtual world is not unlike the joy that Sisyphus saw as the bolder rolled back down the hill.
Today, I am at Engage! Expo, a show about how advertisers and marketers can engage their audiences in virtual worlds. How engaging will the speakers be? What new insights will I come away with? Come back later and find out.
Red Molly at Ridgefield Public Library
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 03/09/2009 - 18:52Every year we go to the Falcon Ridge Folk Festival. We camp for several days and listen to folk music. It takes place in the summer, and it seems like inevitably there are rainstorms. After attending the festival for many years, the events all run together, but there are certain events that stand out.
For example, there was the year that I was going through my divorce. Mairead was probably about nine. She loved dancing at the dance tent. Generally speaking Falcon Ridge is a pretty friendly place and I felt comfortable letting her go off on her own to dance while Miranda and I went to listen to a set at the workshop stage.
During the set, came the announcement that every parent fears. Those fears are compounded if you are in the middle of divorce negotiations about who gets custody of the children in what circumstances. “Would the parents of Mairead Hynes, please report to the medical tent?”
Here, things become a little bit blurry. Did I take Miranda with me? Did I get her to stay with a friend while I ran to the tent? I don’t recall that detail, but Miranda might. What I do remember is that Mairead had been dancing barefoot on the raw plywood floors of the dance stage, and had gotten a horrible sliver. They were working on ways of getting the sliver out. They wanted to use a local anesthetic to numb her foot and they needed my permission. They also hoped that I might be able to calm her down.
In the end, there was a nurse that had a pet ferret or two, again the details are a bit blurry at this point. The ferrets kept Mairead occupied as the medical staff managed to get the sliver out. Later, we ended up getting ferrets as pets.
This has almost nothing to do with Red Molly, and just about everything to do with Red Molly. You see, Red Molly is a band that started at Falcon Ridge five years later. At the campsites, musicians get together and start making music. Three women ended up forming a band one-night singing together at the campsite.
The next day, there was one of those Falcon Ridge rainstorms, and I was riding out the storm under the dance tent. Was Mairead back on the dance floor? Perhaps barefoot again, risking another splinter? The details are blurry. Where were Kim and Fiona? I think they may have gone up to the tent, to get some food, or perhaps for Fiona to take a nap. Fiona would have been about two and a half at the time. I’m pretty sure it was the day after they had first started playing together, but things are blurry.
Maybe it was the following year, when they had their EP out. I do remember getting their EP and Kim asking who they were. Whenever I first heard them, I was struck by how good they were. In 2006 they came back and were the top vote getters on the Emerging Artist Showcase. We picked up their CDs and they ended up becoming one of Fiona’s favorite bands.
When we heard they were going to be doing a free concert at the Ridgefield Public Library, we had to go. We didn’t tell Fiona who the band was going to be until we got there. Tickets were supposed to become available at 1, the doors were to open at 1:30 and the show was to start at 2:00
We got there at about one and already the line was thirty or forty people long. We weren’t sure how many seats there were in the library room, so we waited hopefully in line. Finally a woman came along handing out tickets, and we got ours. I ran over to get hotdogs from the hotdog cart in Ridgefield. Kim had often read about the hotdog cart and wanted one of their dogs. They were very good.
Finally, the line started moving. We walked past a sign that had been put out announcing that the event was full and we were grateful that we had gotten tickets. Inside the room was already mostly full, except for a couple rows of reserved seats in the front. We sat fairly far back and Fiona grumbled. Then, they announced that children could sit on the floor in the front. Fiona went you, with a little coaxing from Kim. Next, a woman told us that two of the seats in the second row were available, since the people whom they had been reserved for didn’t show up. So, we had great seats and Fiona was front and center on the floor.
They started off with a wonderful a cappella song which I hadn’t heard before. Then, there second song, again, if I remember properly, was Summertime. Summertime is a song written by Carolann Solebello, which reached #1 on the Folk DJ Charts.
“In the middle of a field, in the middle of Kansas, in the middle of the summer on the Fourth of July. The wheat was waving. The day was waning. The stars were falling and the world was right. It was summertime and the living was easier back then.”
It is one of Fiona’s favorite songs, yet somehow, it seems like the lyrics ought to be, “In the middle of a field, in the middle of Hillsdale, in the middle of the summer at the end of July. The folks were singing. The day was waning. The stars were falling and the world was right. It was summertime and the living was easier back then.”
Well, Sunday wasn’t summertime. It was one of those first golden spring like days that Robert Frost spoke about in his poem, Nothing Gold Can Stay. Yet the gold did stay. The world was right for two hours as Red Molly sang. They ended off doing an encore singing the wonderful song by Susan Werner, “May I Suggest”.
“May I suggest? May I suggest to you? May I suggest this is the best part of your life? May I suggest? This time is blest for you.”
Well, it was a blessed event. If you get a chance, go hear Red Molly play. If not, at least pick up one of their CDs.
OpenID, XRI, XRDS, and Portable Content
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sun, 03/08/2009 - 11:27I continue to dig into what it would take to build a good Social Network Contact Management System. Yesterday, I had a long discussion with Arron Kallenberg from DandyID. I had talked about my difficulties with the DandyID API and he wanted to address them. In a nutshell, their API is evolving and the documentation had not caught up with the current usage. Now that I know about the updates, I’ve got the API working nicely.
As part of the discussion, we talked about Portable Contacts as a standardized method of receiving contact information that people enter into their social networks. DandyID provides access to information in Portable Contacts format. I also learned that Plaxo is supporting the Portable Contacts API. Details can be found at Portable Contacts at Plaxo. The Plaxo API Endpoint requires OAuth or HTTP Basic authentication, so I started looking at doing OAuth authentication from PHP. I still need to dig deeper into this, especially for trying to call functions from a php script that isn’t part of a webpage.
As I read the Plaxo documentation, I also got interested in XRDS Simple discovery. With that, let me talk about OpenID, XRI and XRDS. OpenID is a method of sharing authentication. In other words, you can use an OpenID userid and password to login to any site that accepts OpenID. This makes it so you need to remember less userids and passwords.
Some people express concern about OpenID phishing. If someone manages to get your OpenID password, they can get to all of the sites you’ve used OpenID with. On the other hand, if someone gets your password, you only need to change it once, instead of either changing the password at a lot of sites which have the same password, or keeping a file somewhere which lists all your passwords for every site you use. I know that I can’t remember all of the passwords I have for all of the sites I’ve registered with, without a bit of help.
Also, using OpenID delegation, you can point back to your site when you use OpenID. For example, I always use OpenID pointing back to my blog when I place comments via Blogger.
This leads me to XRI. XRI is the extensible resource identifier. It is sort of like a URL on steroids. There have been major arguments over when to use URIs and XRIs, but being the geek I am, I have two XRI identifiers that I use regularly, =aldon.hynes and @ahynes1. In XRI, a personal name starts with an equal sign, and an organization name starts with an at sign. I registered @ahynes1 since that works out to be my identification on Twitter, Identi.ca and other services.
One of the things that is interesting about XRIs is that OpenID version 2.0 supports XRIs. So, I can log into services that support OpenID V 2.0 using my id @ahynes1
To support XRI, XRDS, the Extensible Resource Descriptor Sequence was created. It can be used to discover information about a resource. As an example, in OpenID V 2.0, you would use XRDS to find the appropriate OpenID server for a given XRI identity.
With this as groundwork, I am now back to Portable Contacts. My contact information and the other services that I’ve subscribed to is additional information about me and my resources. So, it would be great if we could use XRDS to find servers that provide Portable Contact information about me.
It looks like I can do this using my XRI accounts and DandyID or Plaxo. Both 2idi.com which I use for my =aldon.hynes identity and 1id.com which I use for my @ahynes1 identity provide the ability to edit the ‘service endpoints’ that are revealed through XRDS.
As best as I can tell, what I need to do is add
<service>
<type>http://portablecontacts.net/spec/1.0</type>
<URI>http://www.plaxo.com/pdata/contacts</URI>
</service>
to my XRDS document, and people should be able to find my portable contact information via Plaxo. If I use http://www.dandyid.org/api/poco/ as my URI, they should be able to get my portable contact information from DandyID.
1id.com uses a webform to create this information, and I need to choose options like select, append and priority. I took the default values and we’ll see if they work
You can see my XRDS documents here and .
The next step is to add pointers to them in the header of my blog using the format
<meta http=equiv=”X-XRDS-Location” content=”http://xri.net/=aldon.hynes?_xrd_r=application/xrd%2bxml;sep=false” />
I need to decide if I should use =aldon.hynes or @ahynes1 and if I should have those point to Plaxo or DandyID. Then, I need to find good ways of testing and taking advantage of this. It seems as if Portable Contacts, discovered through XRDS may be a great building block for OpenSocial and other efforts to share information across platforms.
If you’re a non technical blogger, you probably don’t want to start playing with this yet, but you should keep it in the back of your mind as part of the direction social networks may be heading. If you’re more of a geek, kick it around. Share your ideas. Let’s see what we can do with these tools.