Education
Covering the Board of Education
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 06/09/2009 - 21:48I’ve been at plenty of conferences where people talk about what happens when the watchdog, the local media, is asleep, but they all seem to be too theoretical. So I was pleased when I had the opportunity to speak with Massachusetts Democratic Activists at a session at the end of their state convention about citizen journalism. If we want better government, one of the first things we need to do is get more people informed about what is going on.
For me, this has included going to the monthly meetings of my local board of education, tweeting the meetings and writing up blog posts afterwards. I wish more people would do this, and I tried to give attendees to the workshop at the convention enough hints and motivation to get started.
There are many issues that this raises. When bloggers and citizen journalists start covering local meetings, what sort of training should they get? What would be helpful for them to know? What ethical standards apply? I always encourage people to be upfront about how they are, I detest pseudonyms, except in special cases, and talk about any possible conflicts they might have. I encourage people to read the Society of Professional Journalists’ Code of Ethics and check out the Investigative Reporters and Editors website for tips on being a better reporter.
Another thing that always annoys me about all those conference where people talk about the future of journalism is that people go for the simple story, casting it as a battle between the traditional journalists, trained at journalism schools and in danger of losing their jobs and the new bloggers, untrained, unethical, and working for free.
It seems as if the real story is about how interconnected the media ecology is. Today provided a good illustration of this. Rick Green wrote a column for the Hartford Courant entitled Websites Battle For Woodstock's Hearts, Minds. I’ve butted heads with Rick in the past, because he often seems all too willing to jump into tired old story of professionals versus bloggers in a manner that I do not believe does anyone any good. However, this column was noteworthy for taking a more nuanced look at what is going on in the media ecology.
I should note that I am ‘friends’ with Rick on Facebook, and it was through Facebook that I found his column. There is an important lesson here. Traditional media outlets are well advised to use sites like Facebook and Twitter to promote their content and draw in readers.
Beyond that, Rick explored in interesting issue in Woodstock, CT. Today, they had a referendum that would cut the terms of Board of Education members from six years to four years. It would cut the number of members of the Woodstock Board of Education from nine to seven, and the terms of all current Board of Education members would end this November.
Ostensibly, this would make the school board more responsive. Here in Woodbridge, we have four year terms, and I think it would be a good idea for Woodstock to also have four year terms. The Woodbridge Board of Education has nine members, and that seems like an appropriate number of members for the Board of Education. I don’t really see a value in cutting it back to seven members. More importantly, I think that prematurely terminating the terms of the current Board of Education members is a bad idea.
Digging deeper, it appears as if there are a handful of people that have had long standing battles with the Board of Education, and this is just the latest in a long history of skirmishes. Reading blog posts and local newspaper stories, it is possible to draw a more complete view of the issues surrounding legal costs and tuition costs.
What is especially interesting is that The Hartford Courant, still the paper of record for the State of Connecticut commented on the election. In Mr. Green’s column, he pointed to two websites, The Woodstock Café and Woodstock Truth. There has been an ongoing battle between these two websites about the board of education. As Mr. Green notes, the battles aren’t always pretty, but it is good to see people more engaged.
I should also note that the Woodstock Villager has provided good coverage of issues around the local board of education as well. All of this points, I believe to the importance of the state paper of record, the local papers, and the blogs, all providing different perspectives about the events in our state. While I wouldn’t wish the drama of Woodstock on other towns in our state, I do wish that other towns had people as interested in the board of education as it appears people in Woodstock are.
As a final note, according to the Woodstock Café, the referendum failed 61% TO 39%
Tinkering with Students’ Lives
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Fri, 05/29/2009 - 17:49In December 1965, a thirteen year old student wore a black armband to school to protest the Vietnam war. It was a small act, and did not lead to any immediate de-escalation of the conflict in Vietnam. She probably didn’t expect her arm band to end the war, but she also probably didn’t expect it to change her life, and the life of others that way it did.
Four years later, the Supreme Court ruled that the school violated Ms. Tinker’s First Amendment Freedom of Speech when they sent her home for wearing that armband.
Last night, she spoke at the ACLU of Connecticut’s Milton Sorokin Symposium, “Students and Schools Pushing the Limits of Free Speech”. The evening started off with Justice Richard N. Palmer presenting the 2009 First Amendment Essay Contest winners. These students had written essays on the topic, “In what circumstance should a school be able to punish students for their speech off campus?”
The evening was moderated by Laurie Perez of Fox 61 News who has written about the Doninger case and noted that this case is the most searched item on the Fox 61 News website.
Many lawyers seemed star struck to be in the presence of a plaintiff of such an important Supreme Court case. What sort of message would Ms. Tinker deliver? How had the event changed her life? What were the influences that led her to wearing the arm band on that fateful day, and what had her life turned out to be like forty years later?
Ms. Tinker spoke about her father being a Methodist minister and how she had been brought up with the exhortation to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. She spoke about moving out of one town because of her father’s involvement in the Civil Rights movement and dinner time discussions about her parents’ experiences going to register voters in the south in 1964.
She commented that “That’s the sort of person I want to be, to stand up for what is right”, and spoke about the importance of telling stories not only about Cinderella, but also about brave people who stood up for what they believed in.
Clearly, her parents’ simple acts of courage had a hand in shaping her life, as did her experiences with the famous lawsuit. She became a nurse and works mostly with trauma patients; gunshots, knifings, and accidents. She spends her free time going from one event to another, trying to help students find their voices, to stand up for themselves, and to lead the way to a better world.
She spoke as a nurse, recognizing that one of the most important things a student can do for their long term health is graduate from high school. She spoke about advocating for ‘democratic schools’ and noted that a punitive approach to education, especially regarding what happens beyond the school yard gate drives students away from schools. She talked about the problems with the school to prison pipeline.
In many ways, her talk could be summed up in the simple words she often tells students, “You are going to make history with your small actions or inactions”. As she spoke, I thought of a different quote from Robert Kennedy:
"Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring, those ripples build a current that can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance."
Her parents sent forth a tiny ripple of hope, it crossed the ripple of hope she and her fellow students sent out, it now crosses the ripples of hope sent out by the students whose lives she has touched as she goes around the country encouraging students to speak up.
After she spoke, Patrice McCarthy, Deputy Director and General Counsel for the Connecticut Association of Boards of Education spoke. It must be following such a powerful speaker, but Ms. McCarthy held her own and her remarks and the question and answer period deserve their own post.
So, I put up my blog posts and wonder what sort of effect my small actions might make. I wonder about the actions of other bloggers I visit online. We may never see the effect of our actions the way Ms. Tinker has, but we should all keep to our little actions and our hopes for a better world.
Obituary for an Unknown Heroine
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Tue, 05/19/2009 - 18:41Yesterday, I was told of a sad loss for our community. A ninety-nine year old woman whom I don’t believe I ever met passed away recently. I don’t know if she ever came to the town I live in, and I’m don’t even know her full name, but she has had an important influence on my life.
When we moved to Woodbridge, everyone told us what a wonderful superintendent Dr. Guy Stella was. Over the past two years, I’ve gotten to know Dr. Stella as I attended school board meetings, technology meetings at the school, parent teacher organization meetings and numerous other events. I told him about Fiona’s radio show and he asked her to come down to his office and tell him about the show. He has made Beecher Road School a much better place and I am grateful to him for this.
Once, I had the opportunity to ask him if he would call into Fiona’s show. I explained that it was every Sunday at 6:30. He said that he would love to, but that every Sunday he goes to visit his mother. I suggested that his mother should call in, and thought about how great it would be for students at Beecher Road to hear stories about the childhood of their beloved superintendent.
Unfortunately, I have been told that Dr. Stella’s mother passed away recently. She will not get a chance to call into Fiona’s radio show. I won’t get a chance to meet or talk with her. However, she must have been a remarkable woman to have a son turn out so wonderfully.
My condolences go out to Dr. Stella and his entire family. As we take a moment to pause and reflect, I think it is important to think about the effect we all may have, not only on those that we spend a lot of time with, our family and friends, but also the indirect effect our lives may have on people we never meet, the way I am sure Dr. Stella’s mother has had an important effect on children in many places where Dr. Stella has worked.
Sotomayor and Doninger
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sat, 05/02/2009 - 21:14Professor Paul Levinson of Fordham University has written an interesting post asserting that Sotomayor's Bad 1st Amendment Decision Should Disqualify Her.
The bad decision is the Second Circuit of Appeals decision in the Doninger case.
I was at the hearing where Attorney Jon Schoenhorn's Arguments in the Doninger Case at the Second Circuit.
In my beginning of the month blog post about the search for a new Supreme Court Justice I wrote:
She [Sotomayor] has an impressive background, and she asked good questions during the hearing, but I disagree with her ruling, at least in that case. It did not seem as if the justices did their homework.
I'm not sure if I would go as far as Professor Levinson in arguing that her decision in the Doninger case should disqualify her. However, I do believe that it raises very significant issues that will need to be addressed in a Senate Confirmation hearing, in the event that it should go that far.
(For previous posts about the Doninger case, see the Doninger category of my blog.)
- Aldon Hynes's blog
- Login to post comments
- Comments
Liveblogging Woodbridge Board of Education Meeting
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 04/27/2009 - 19:44With one week to go until the municipal elections in Woodbridge, which includes five seats on the Woodbridge Board of Education, the board gathered for their monthly board meeting. After starting with some technology issues and then a salute to the flag, Dr. Stella gave his Superintendent’s report.
He started off by talking about concern Swine Flu. He mentioned that there have been lots of media inquiries and spoke about a conference call with the National Association of Nurses, the Center for Disease Control, the White House, the Department of Homeland Security, and other organizations.
Dr. Stella noted that things are rapidly changing and the reports are now that fifty people have been identified as having contracted the swine flu in the United States, and only two have been hospitalized, both of whom are recovering.
The school will be communicating with the community using letters and updates to the school website. Other aspects being considered includes establishing a long term policy concerning health issues, and ways to address health issues as part of the curriculum, including especially a focus on the importance of washing hands.
Dr. Stella’s report continued with a focus on Twenty-First Century skills. There was a discussion about students from Hong Kong coming to do a presentation at Beecher Road, the two teachers that went to China and the use of Skype to connect teachers, students and parents here in Connecticut with their counterparts in China. Hopefully, Skype will continue to be used frequently going forward.
Dr. Stella also attended a meeting with top executives at Unilever, where the topic was education and Twenty First Century skills. The executives spoke of the importance twenty-first century skills and recognized Beecher Road for its successes.