Thought for today
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 08/03/2005 - 14:34
President Bush has asked that the Senate conduct hearings in a fair and timely manner concerning the confirmation of Judge John Roberts.
Given our nation's concern about not allowing extremists new opportunities to damage our country, I hope that Judge Roberts' hearings are as fair and timely as the hearings of those detained at Guantanamo Bay.
Thought for Today
Submitted by Anonymous on Wed, 08/03/2005 - 21:12. span>I know that you do not support President Bush but it is refreshing to see you address the office of the President with the respect it deserves. Some of your fellow bloggers should learn this. I have been reading the Starfire blog and respect the opinions given (although in most cases do not agree) but I am sickened that he refers to the President as bush and the administration as flying monkeys. I believe that regardless of the person in the office, the office of President should be respected.
Thank you
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 08/08/2005 - 15:47. span>You are right in observing that I have strong disagreements with President Bush on many of the policies of his administration. I am especially concerned about the legislative and judicial branches remaining free and equal branches of the government, providing the checks and balances that our country has been built upon.
Our country has also been built upon open and friendly political debate. The name calling that takes place on both sides of the debate, in my mind only contributes to further weaken our country.
Decorum
Submitted by DavidMeyer on Wed, 08/03/2005 - 23:39. span>I hope that all the Senators on the Judiciary Committee will temper their personal notions of "extremist" with the deference traditionally shown to the sitting President's choices for the bench. They are supposed to be weeding out Klansmen, not those who merely deviate from today's notion of political correctness.
Aldon, the sarcastic innuendo of the second paragraph is beneath you. If you think Judge Roberts is unfit for the Supreme Court, I'd like to hear why.
--
David Meyer
Takarazuka, Japan
papa@jtan.com
Guantanamo and the Judge
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Mon, 08/08/2005 - 15:42. span>David, et al.,
I am particularly concerned about what appears to be an erosion of due process in the United States. I believe that limitations to this due process presents a dangerous threat. Guantanamo is an example of this erosion, as is provisions of the Patriot act. I do not believe that Judge Roberts is a dangerous extremist in the way that a member of the klan is, and I believe that Judge Roberts, members of the klan, and detainees at Guantanamo as deserve fair and speedy hearings.
Yet even this raises concerns in my mind about Judge Roberts. A recent article in the Wall Street Journal says this:
During Judge Roberts's time as principal deputy solicitor general in the administration of George H.W. Bush, his office chose to get involved in dozens of state cases to limit the rights of criminal defendants. The cases backed state prosecutors seeking to preserve convictions won with warrantless searches and confessions obtained without Miranda warnings about the right to remain silent; to dismiss claims by inmates of "cruel and unusual punishments"; and to validate aggressive law-enforcement techniques, such as sobriety checkpoints and "protective sweeps" of crime-infested dwellings.