Flags... and the People Who Wave Them.
While surfing at Blog Explosion, I stumbled across an interesing blog entry, where the writer rants about flag waving three year olds. She writes, "There's nothing more moving than a small, impressionable child in the midst of a crowd waving a piece of cloth that represents your country, is there? ... I have to admit I get a different feeling when I see pictures like this. It's a sinking, disconnected feeling -- disgust, even."
I wrote the following response:
I would like to take a slightly different tack, especially since I am one of those hard core liberals in the United States, and since my three year old daughter loves to wave the flag.
First, do not confuse flag waving or patriotism with conservativism. I stand in a long line of liberals wrapping themselves in the flag and saying, "it is our flag too."
Second, while you may belittle the person that asks, "Why?" all the time, we need more people asking "why?" Why are we in Iraq? Why have social programs been cut? Why is the deficit (which my daughter will inherit) ballooning? Why are our rights eroding? Why is the environment getting worse?
If more people were like three year olds and asking why more often, we wouldn't be having the problems we are currently having.
As a final comment, I believe you underestimate what a three year old understands. I've talked with three year olds and I've talked with fifty year old conservatives. Often, the three year olds demonstrate a much higher level of understanding of the issues that face our country than the fifty year old conservatives.
They might talk in simpler terms about sharing nicely, not hitting people, appreciating the flowers around us and showing concern for people that are sick, but their understanding is often much greater than the fifty year old conservative.
Did you get a reply?
Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 10/15/2004 - 12:13. span>We have similar problems with flag wavers in the UK. In the 1970s, the Union Flag was most often waved by far right parties and those on the left, ethnic minorities and others felt alienated or even intimidated by it. Only now is it being reclaimed for all Britons and it's interesting to see it appear regularly in Asian music videos, for example.
Anyway. You're right to worry about your flag and to remind fellow liberals how important it is to rally behind it and help it symbolise a positive identity for the whole country.
Stephen Newton
www.stephennewton.com
Its always good to see I'm no
Submitted by ang6666 on Tue, 10/19/2004 - 22:44. span>Its always good to see I'm not the only one who has issues with kids waving flags ... or saying the pledge ... or anything of that nature.
Personally I feel they are too young to understand what it is that they are doing, and what it represents. It may look cute to some, but its nothing but brainwashing to me.
Angie
Ang's Weird Ideas