Seminary
ISO A Third Space Eschatology Affinity Group #CDSPTheology #CLMOOC
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sat, 03/02/2019 - 22:01I am an almost sixty-year-old cis-het Euro-American male Low Residency Masters of Divinity student at Church Divinity School of the Pacific. During the fall and spring terms, I take classes online, discussing the texts in the schools learning management system. I head out to California in January and June for brief intensive courses. Because of this, my experiences with theological education are different from many other theology students. For me, this is compounded by some of the interests I bring to my studies.
I’ve worked with computers since the 1960s. I’ve been on the Internet since the early 1980s. I’ve developed an interest in digital pedagogy that has led me down many rabbit holes. I’ve learned about Deleuze and Guattari from online affinity groups. I’ve become interested in connected learning, postcolonialism, speech act theory, third space theory, poststructuralism, and a raft of writers such as Foucault, Lacan, and others. However, my knowledge in all these areas is rudimentary at best.
For my day job, I’m a communications manager at a Federally Qualified Health Center. I started there, close to a decade ago, as their first social media manager, and social media remains very important to me. That said, I’m ambivalent about much church social media. It too often feels like it is more focused on marketing and less focused on formation or transformation than I would like.
Some of this changed with a course I took last fall entitled “Postmodern Christian Education”. As part of the course, we read John Roberto’s “Reimagining Faith Formation for the 21st Century”. In the book, he presented the idea of a “Faith Formation Network” which is sort of like a personal learning network focused on issues of faith. The idea particularly grabbed me and is helping catalyze some of my thinking around faith, education, and digital media.
One group I’ve interacted with is the Connected Learning MOOC. This month, they are starting up a slow read of Affinity Online: How Connection and Shared Interest Fuel Learning by Mizuko Ito et al. I don’t really have time to add this to all my other reading, but since it’s a slow read and they invite people to join in as they can, I figured I’ll read and comment when I can. Their opening questions are “What is an affinity network?” and “what characteristics do affinity networks have?”
The book starts by talking about a young woman who ends up part of a Harry Potter related fiber artists group. In the old days, it was unlikely she would have found “a critical mass of knitters who are also Harry Potter Fans.” (Ito, 1)
I’ve read a little bit, here and there, about postcolonialism and third space theory, but I know very few people that are well versed in it and certainly haven’t found a third space theory affinity group. So, when I started wondering about how third space theory might apply to eschatology, I didn’t really have a good place to go, other than wondering the digital library stacks in search of a lead.
So, to the list of things I’m studying this semester, I’m adding an exploration into affinity groups, an explanation into Third Space Eschatology, and ideally hoping to find or develop a third space eschatology affinity group. Thoughts?
No Person is a Snowflake
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sat, 02/16/2019 - 13:06Written in response to a discussion in my Christian Ethics class as we discussed climate change; with apologies to John Donne.
No person is a snowflake entire of itself; every person
is a piece of the glacier, a part of the main;
if a piece of the glacier be washed away by the sea, our climate
is the less…
All climate change diminishes me,
because I am involved in our climate.
And therefore never send to know for whom
the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.
Fear and Blessing
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Wed, 01/23/2019 - 12:12For my classmates at CDSP
How frightening it is
to realize
that just maybe
we aren’t imposters
and that God really does love us
more than we can understand.
What a blessing it is
to worship
with emerging leaders
in a variety of styles.
What a blessing it is
to reflect with friends
on who we really are
who God really is
and how we should live.
What a blessing it is
to experience
God’s unsurpassed love
through the saints gathered around us.
Saturday at CDSP
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sat, 01/19/2019 - 12:36It is Saturday morning. I am eating my oatmeal and making the transition from the first week of the Winter Intensive to the second week. Some very dear classmates have headed home. Others are arriving. I’m going through my notes from last week to organize them as much as possible. I’m going through my readings for next week to be as prepared as possible. I have other stuff to do as well; laundry, meeting with Gay Clark Jennings, getting a little walking and decompressing done.
The first week was wonderful. I am so looking forward to the second week.
An Easy People's Liturgy
Submitted by Aldon Hynes on Sun, 11/04/2018 - 08:44We sat around the table and drank a bottle of wine…
We were listening to “Easy People” by The Neilds, but we weren’t actually drinking a bottle of wine. We were playing YouTube Riff Off. My youngest daughter was home from college with a friend and we were playing songs off our cellphones, mostly from YouTube. A person would play a song, and then the next person would play some song that they associated with the previous song, riffing off the previous song.
Perhaps I’ve been too engrossed in my studies, but I looked at us around the table and thought about what I’m reading for Postmodern Christian Education in seminary. Juan M. C. Oliver in Worship-Shaped Life writes,
I cannot overemphasize how dangerous is the failure to incarnate our worship in the local time, place, and culture.
(Oliver, 13)
The YouTube Riff Off felt more incarnated in our local time, place, and culture than many church services I attend. I wondered, how do we make liturgy more like a YouTube Riff Off?
When ritual isn’t tied to local time, place, and culture, it can become highly problematic. Oliver talks about the relationship between ritual and colonialism. It became very easy for Anglicans in British colonies to confuse rituals of the Reign of God with rituals of the British Empire.
I love the rituals of liturgy, and yet Oliver’s warning rang true. How much do we love rituals because they are different, and take us out of our daily lives, and how much do we love rituals because they connect us with something greater? It seems like a good liturgy should do both. However, at times I’ve participated in liturgies that have done neither.
Put another way, liturgy should be about meaning-making, and “meaning-making takes community” (Oliver 19). There was a lot of meaning shared in the songs around the dinner table. Heartbreak, longing, hope.
Haven't I paid my dues by now, don't I get the right to choose?
And I choose you to take up all of my time
I choose you because you're funny and kind
I want easy people from now on
As we played our music, I thought back to times when I had first heard the songs; times with friends in college, times with my children when they were little. There is something very liturgical there. Some of the church services that I find most moving are those that connect me to saints throughout the ages. Oliver talks about the importance of things “older and greater than us, and outlasting us.” (Oliver 11) Thursday was All Saints day, so I feel particularly focused on the great cloud of witnesses of the Christian faith over the centuries right now. I think about this during various church services. Am I getting a sense of a timeless tradition being incarnate in my local time, space, and culture? I love it when I do get that sense, praying in an old monastery with walls soaked in prayers of generations of monks, praying in a church using language, images, sounds, and smells that have accompanied the saints for ages.
So now, as Oliver suggests, I am reflecting on last night’s secular ritual of YouTube Riff Off as I prepare for todays ritual of Eucharist. (Oliver, 20). May the timeless be as locally and culturally incarnate in todays worship as it was in last night’s gathering.