Have you left no sense of decency?
(Originally posted at Greater Democracy)
As I have spoken about before, I like the sense a narrative in politics. I like tying in stories that people remember and that resonates with them.
Popular stories include the emperor’s new clothes, the boy who cried wolf, and perhaps Pinocchio. However, there is another story that I like to talk about, which I don’t think is getting enough attention.
On June 9th, 1954, Joseph Welch confronted Senator Joseph McCarthy, asking him, “Have you left no sense of decency?”. As an aside, for a transcript, and a wonderful recording of the interchange, please check out: http://www.americanrhetoric.com/speeches/welch-mccarthy.html
The recent advertisements by Swift Boats for Bush raise some interesting questions. To what extent were the activities illegally coordinated? What role should 527s have in the political process? However, the most important question to ask of Swift Boats for Bush is, “Have you left no sense of decency?”
Yesterday, I received a message concerning the College Republicans. They are encouraging people to grow their chapters through Young America's Foundation's 9/11: Never Forget Project. Needless to say, the College Democrats have criticized the CRNC for Politicizing 9/11.
The Washington Post writes:
Young America's Foundation suggests, among other things, holding a moment of prayer at home football games to mark the anniversary and will provide free posters, buttons and other materials. But it's in no way, shape or form political, Patrick Coyle, director of campus programs, assured us.
"We're using this in a way to get the members active," he said. "The reason why we started this program in the first place is that a lot of schools weren't doing anything for the anniversary."
This year, the foundation Web site says, its 9/11 speakers include Dave Bossie, a certified Bill Clinton antagonist who has written a book called "Intelligence Failure: How Clinton's National Security Policy Set the Stage for 9/11." A nonpolitical title if we've ever heard one.
This too raises the question, “Have you left no sense of decency?”
Unwelcome Distraction
Submitted by Anonymous on Fri, 08/27/2004 - 09:33. span>Aldon,
Whatever the veracity of the claims by the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, I am deeply frustrated by this entire excursion into the past. It has opened old wounds unnecessarily and added to the sense of division, at a time when we should be trying to bring the country together. One can blaim all this on the Bush campaign, but it is equally true that Kerry made a conscious choice to make his Vietnam service a central issue of his campaign--a deliberate gambit to counter the perception of Bush as Commander-In-Chief.
As a basic character reference, in my book it gets Kerry higher marks than Bush for having served in combat--apparently with distinction--when Bush chose the Air National Guard. But Bush gets higher marks on this than others who simply sat the war out with deferrals or fled the country. But how much should any of this count for, 35 years later? I'm much more interested in Kerry's legislative record, about which I've only heard from his opponents, than his bravery in Vietnam. Leading America is simply not the same as skippering a Swift Boat.
Geoff Styles
(Aldon, I'm not sure why my response came up as "anonymous".)